Community comparison · Weston, FL
Windmill Ranch Estates vs Windmill Reserve
Windmill Ranch Estates and Windmill Reserve are two of the most expensive communities in Weston, and both are guard gated with homes of about 7,000 square feet and up. Windmill Ranch Estates is the older one, 281 homes from 1987 to 2013 on lots of about 1.4 acres, with equestrian privileges. Windmill Reserve is 83 custom homes built from 2005 to 2023 on lots of about three quarters of an acre, laid out around lakes and a nature preserve.
Side by side → Homes for sale in bothSide by side
Windmill Ranch Estates vs Windmill Reserve at a glance
| Windmill Ranch Estates | Windmill Reserve | |
|---|---|---|
| Homes | 281 single family | 83 single family |
| Built | 1987 to 2013 | 2005 to 2023 |
| Typical lot | About 1.4 acres | About 3/4 acre |
| Median home size | About 7,200 sq ft | About 7,500 sq ft |
| Entry | Guard gated | Guard gated |
| Horses | Equestrian privileges | |
| Sales since Jan 2025 | 13 | 6 |
| Median sale | $3.75M | $3.54M |
Homes, build years and living area: Broward County Property Appraiser records in the Florida Department of Revenue parcel file. Sales: qualified sales recorded January 2025 through June 2026, the same window as the Weston neighborhoods table. Updated November 16, 2026. Compiled by Anthony Spitaleri.
The short version
Windmill Ranch Estates
- More land: the typical lot is close to an acre and a half.
- Listings mention equestrian privileges, so you can have the land and the horses.
- A median sale of $3.75M on 13 sales since January 2025.
Windmill Reserve
- Every home is a custom build, from French chateau to modern.
- Newer, with homes going up as late as 2023, on lots of about three quarters of an acre.
- A median sale of $3.54M on 6 sales since January 2025.
Which one fits
How I’d think about it
If you want acreage and room for horses, Windmill Ranch Estates is the one. If you want a newer custom home and don't need the extra land, look at Windmill Reserve. At this price, the individual home matters more than the median, so what I would suggest is look at both before you decide.
For the full picture, read my guides to Windmill Ranch Estates and Windmill Reserve.
On the market
Homes for sale in Windmill Ranch Estates
Homes for sale in Windmill Reserve
Both communities are small enough that the right home might not be listed today. Tell me what you’re looking for and I’ll send you homes as they come up.
Questions I get
FAQ
Which has bigger lots, Windmill Ranch Estates or Windmill Reserve?
Windmill Ranch Estates. Its typical lot is about 1.4 acres, compared with about three quarters of an acre in Windmill Reserve.
Which costs more?
From January 2025 through June 2026, the median qualified sale was $3.75M in Windmill Ranch Estates on 13 sales and $3.54M in Windmill Reserve on 6 sales, based on county records.
Can you have horses in Windmill Ranch Estates?
Listings in Windmill Ranch Estates mention equestrian privileges. I always suggest you confirm the rules for the specific property with the association.
More comparisons
Other neighbors, side by side
Still deciding?
Let’s grab a coffee and talk it through.
I’ll walk you through both communities, what’s actually selling and what I’d watch for in each. If you own in either one, I’m happy to put together an equity report for your home. And let me know your coffee of choice.
Book a time to talk → or call 954 235 5783Anthony Spitaleri, Broker Associate, REALTOR®, Coldwell Banker Realty, 2400 N. Commerce Parkway, Suite 105, Weston, FL 33326. License BK3281907. Information is believed accurate but not guaranteed. Verify school assignments, flood zones, association requirements and taxes for any specific property.




